PEOPLE vs. ESCOTE (Criminal Law Review 1)

G.R. No. 140756. April 4, 2003

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, vs. JUAN GONZALES ESCOTE, JR. @ Jun Mantika of Sta. Lucia, Angat, Bulacan and VICTOR ACUYAN y OCHOVILLOS @ Vic Arroyo of Sto. Nio, Poblacion, Bustos, Bulacan, accused-appellants.

FACTS:

September 28, 1996 at past midnight, Rodolfo Cacatian, the regular driver of Five Star Passenger Bus drove the bus from its terminal at Pasay City to its destination in Bolinao, Pangasinan. Also on board was Romulo Digap, the regular conductor of the bus, as well as some passengers. At Camachile, Balintawak, six passengers boarded the bus, including Victor Acuyan and Juan Gonzales Escote, Jr. who were wearing maong pants, rubber shoes, hats and jackets. Another passenger, SPO1 Jose C. Manio, Jr., a resident of Angeles City, was seated at the rear portion of the bus on his way home to Angeles City. Tucked on his waist was his service gun. Every now and then, Rodolfo looked at the side view mirror as well as the rear view and center mirrors installed atop the drivers seat to monitor any incoming and overtaking vehicles and to observe the passengers of the bus.

The lights of the bus were on even as some of the passengers slept. When the bus was travelling along the highway in Plaridel, Bulacan, Juan and Victor suddenly stood up, whipped out their handguns and announced a holdup. Petrified, Rodolfo glanced at the center mirror towards the passengers seat and saw Juan and Victor armed with handguns. Juan fired his gun upward to awaken and scare off the passengers. Victor followed suit and fired his gun upward. Juan and Victor then accosted the passengers and divested them of their money and valuables.

Juan divested Romulo of the fares he had collected from the passengers. The felons then went to the place Manio, Jr. was seated and demanded that he show them his identification card and wallet. Manio, Jr. brought out his identification card bearing No. 00898.3 Juan and Victor took the identification card of the police officer as well as his service gun and told him: Pasensya ka na Pare, papatayin ka namin, baril mo rin and papatay sa iyo. The police officer pleaded for mercy: Pare maawa ka sa akin : May pamilya ako. However, Victor and Juan ignored the plea of the police officer and shot him on the mouth, right ear, chest and right side of his body. 

The robbers assured Rodolfo that if the latter will follow their instructions, he will not be harmed. Victor and Juan ordered Rodolfo to stop the bus along the overpass in Mexico, Pampanga where they alighted from the bus. The robbery was over in 25 minutes.

When the bus reached Dau, Mabalacat, Pampanga, Rodolfo and Romulo forthwith reported the incident to the police authorities.

ISSUE:

Whether treachery is generic aggravating circumstance in a crime of robbery with homicide.

RULING:

Treachery is a generic aggravating circumstance to robbery with homicide although said crime is classified as a crime against property and a single and indivisible crime. Treachery is not a qualifying circumstance because as ruled by the Supreme Court of Spain in its decision dated September 11, 1878, the word homicide is used in its broadest and most generic sense.

The Court agrees with the trial court that treachery was attendant in the commission of the crime. There is treachery when the following essential elements are present, viz: (a) at the time of the attack, the victim was not in a position to defend himself; and (b) the accused consciously and deliberately adopted the particular means, methods or forms of attack employed by him. The essence of treachery is the sudden and unexpected attack by an aggressor on the unsuspecting victim, depriving the latter of any chance to defend himself and thereby ensuring its commission without risk of himself. Treachery may also be appreciated even if the victim was warned of the danger to his life where he was defenseless and unable to flee at the time of the infliction of the coup de grace.

In the case at bar, the victim suffered six wounds, one on the mouth, another on the right ear, one on the shoulder, another on the right breast, one on the upper right cornea of the sternum and one above the right iliac crest. Juan and Victor were armed with handguns. They first disarmed SPO1 Manio, Jr. and then shot him even as he pleaded for dear life. When the victim was shot, he was defenseless. He was shot at close range, thus insuring his death. The victim was on his way to rejoin his family after a hard days work. Instead, he was mercilessly shot to death, leaving his family in grief for his untimely demise. The killing is a grim example of the utter inhumanity of man to his fellowmen.